Skip to content
January 13, 2012 / JG

My Brilliant Career

My Brilliant Career, Miles Franklin, 1901

Straight from writing about Holden Caulfield I finished reading about another wonderfully realised teen character from another time and halfway around the world. Sybylla Penelope Melvin.

Franklin’s turn of the (last) century novel is a classic, and rightly so. This short semi-autobiographical coming of age tale was a best seller, both in Australia, and back in England, but the scandal it generated caused Franklin to request that it not be published again until after her death.

I picked up this book as part of Meanjin Tournament of Books late last year, and am pleased that it will be the first of my reviews for the Australian Women Writers Challenge.

Sybylla is a cocky teenage girl, all slang and rebellion. She is stubborn, intelligent, and uncompromising. When her impoverished farmer parents can no longer afford to maintain their ever expanding brood she is shipped off to her grandmother’s at Caddagat to live in relative middle class comfort. It is here she meets, and is fallen in love with by, Harold Beecham.

A life of relative married ease is not however part of Sybylla’s ambitions.

Girls! girls! Those of you who have hearts, and therefore a wish for happiness, homes, and husbands by and by, never develop a reputation of being clever. It will put you out of the matrimonial running as effectually as though it had been circulated that you had leprosy… A plain woman will have nothing forgiven her. Her fate is such that the parents of uncomely female infants should be compelled to put them to death at their birth.

This is not an Austenesque romance tale, in which after much trial and tribulation, the precocious young lady finally marries into love and comfort. Sybylla’s bravery in turning down her suitor, in refusing to compromise, is heart breaking. She refuses a life of relative ease with Harold to remain with her unloving mother, in the monotony and grind of their poverty.

It is not marriage that is Sybylla’s crowning achievement, the act which secures her place as one of the most compelling of Australian heroines, but her refusal to be anyone but herself, and that self is a writer, not a wife. The book ends with her writing her masterpiece, that we know, even if Sybylla does not, will be an enduring classic of the Australian literary canon.

This book is also notable for its stunning descriptions of the Australian landscape, and turn of the century rural life:

A few light, wind-smitten clouds made wan streaks across the white sky, haggard with the fierce, relentless glare of the afternoon sun. Weariness was written across my mother’s delicate careworn features, and found expression in my father’s knitted brows and dusty face. Blackshaw was weary, and said so as he wiped the dust, made mud with perspiration, off his cheeks. I was weary – my limbs ached with the heat and work. The poor beast stretched at our feet was weary. All nature was weary, and seemed to sing a dirge to that effect in the furnace-breath wind which roared among the trees on the low ranges at our back and smote the parched and thirsty ground. All were weary, all but the sun. He seemed to glory in his power, relentless and untiring, as he swung boldly in the sky, triumphantly leering down upon his helpless victims.

Franklin brings to life the heat and dust, the strain and hardship of the 1890s drought and recession. While her descriptions can tend to the parochial they are not mawkish or overblown.

This is a passionate and precocious book, but most of all is Franklin’s brutal honesty and stunning bravery that strikes me most. This is a book that deserves to be read, and I’m embarrassed to admit that it took me so long to do so.

Advertisement

9 Comments

Leave a Comment
  1. shelleyrae @ Book'd Out / Jan 18 2012 4:32 pm

    Congratulations on posting your first review for AWW.!

  2. Michelle ~ Book to the Future / Jan 18 2012 10:32 pm

    Hi – I was having a look around the reviews posted so far for the Australian Women Writers’ Challenge and noticed your review. I *adored* My Brilliant Career!! It was the second or third book I reviewed when I first started blogging, so Sybylla will always have a special place in my heart.

    Excellent review! I’m looking forward to finding out what you’re reading next.

    • JG / Jan 19 2012 10:17 am

      Thanks Michelle – I really enjoy reading your blog, so welcome!

      Next up will be Carpentaria – which is taking me a lot longer to get through than My Brilliant Career!

      • Michelle ~ Book to the Future / Jan 19 2012 11:11 pm

        Ooh, Carpentaria is in my Giant Pile of Books I’m yet to read! I’ll have to report back and see what you thought.

  3. Claire Corbett / Jan 18 2012 10:46 pm

    Gorgeous quote. Thanks for your review – it’s important to remember why some books should continue to be read. I read this years ago but will probably have to reread. Vividly remember the scenes of Sybylla trying to teach the McSwat (?) kids. It’s probably hard for contemporary readers to see why Sybylla had to choose between marriage and being a writer and even in the 70s it outraged many people when the film came out, including, famously, critic Pauline Kael.

    But the reality in Miles Franklin’s day was so very different and it’s important to remember how unfree married women generally were, especially as they probably had no control over their fertility.

    • JG / Jan 19 2012 10:21 am

      Hi Claire, thanks for commenting!
      I found myself really rooting for Sybylla to marry Harry, just so this book could conform to my expectations for a ‘romance’ novel of the 19th C. But I kept having to check myself, and be like, “No way! She doesn’t have to get married if she doesn’t want to.” And I think that’s what I really loved about it — how Sybylla’s choices kept confounding my expectations and assumptions about how a young woman should behave at that time (and the tropes of the plucky young heroine absorbed from compulsively re-reading Austen and the Brontes).

  4. Sean the Bookonaut / Jan 18 2012 10:48 pm

    Count me embarrassed as well, we have a copy but I have never read it. A brilliant review if I may say so.

  5. Tony / Jan 20 2012 12:52 pm

    This is a great review of a book I’m planning to read soon :) I’m currently reading Carre Tiffany’s ‘Everyman’s Rules for Scientific Living’, and while the times are different, the idea of a woman’s duty is very similar…

Trackbacks

  1. Dabbling in writing by Australian women #2 | Reactions to Reading

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.